Wednesday, February 23, 2011
Federal Judge In D.C. Upholds Health Care Reform, Says Some Arguments 'Ignore Reality'
Tuesday, December 15, 2009
The Great Health Care Give-Away of 2009
In an earlier blog post I explained why health care insurance reform without a robust public option is a huge government give-away to the private health insurance industry. But that is just what is coming out of the US Senate this week. Harry Reid has reportedly dumped both the public option and the idea that people 55-64 years of age should be able to buy into Medicare, in order appease Joe Lieberman (the Senator from Aetna), Ben Nelson (another recipient of insurance industry largesse) and other conservadems.
This is truly outrageous! What we are getting from the Sausage Factory that is the Senate is a bill that will require millions of Americans to purchase expensive private health insurance, many of whom will be subsidized by taxpayers dollars in order to do so, with absolutely no mechanism to prevent these corporations from using the proceeds to pad their profit margins. This is disgraceful.
Progressives need to learn a lesson from this. The reason why this happened is nicely summed up in an article by John Neffinger "Why We Lost Health Care." The US Senate is a dysfunctional and undemocratic institution.
Former Vermont Governor Howard Dean has now called upon democrats to "Kill the Senate Bill" and start over with the House of Representatives. Without a public option or a Medicare buy-in provision it is not real reform at all. It is just a huge corporate welfare bill for the private insurance industry.
The people need to rise up and demand better of their government.
Thursday, September 10, 2009
A health insurance mandate without the public option is a real loser
In his speech last night President Obama for the first time made it clear that he will be insisting on a mandate for individuals and most companies to buy health insurance.
This is a huge boon for the private insurance companies who stand to gain millions of new members. However, if as proposed they will not be allowed to "cherry pick" subscribers or deny benefits for pre-existing conditions, then their bottom-lines will also take a hit.
The natural thing for them to do would be to pass on these additional costs to their members in the form of higher premiums, larger deductibles, fewer benefits or all three.
If there is no strong national nonprofit public health insurance plan they are competing with, this is just what they will do. The result will be a government mandated windfall for the private insurance companies, and higher (not lower) premiums for the insured.
With a public plan, however, they will be forced to offset the increased costs of "stable and secure" health insurance with real efficiencies and even, perhaps, by forgoing some profits and disappointing their Wall Street analysts.
This is why having a public health insurance option is so essential to the overall effectiveness of health insurance reform.
Wishing to secure insurance industry profits, some Repbulicans are now proposing that there be a waiting period before the public plan is introduced, and suggesting a trigger under which it would only be introduced after this period if the anticipated cost savings in health insurance do not materialize.
The idea of delaying implementation of a public option so the insurance companies can enjoy several more years of windfall profits is crap that ought to be firmly rejected. Those who favor this idea are counting on being able to demonstrate that the reforms enacted this year did not reduce costs (as they won't without a public option) and then arguing for their repeal hoping that this will give them an issue to regain control of the Congress several years down the line. In the meanwhile their allies in the private insurance business will be reaping the benefits. This is why stock in the major private insurers rose after Obama's speech.
Addendum (9/11/09) An interesting commentary by R J Eskow published this morning makes a similar argument while also explaining why health insurance company stocks went up the day after the President's speech.
Addendum (9/12/09) Jed Lewison has also noticed that a mandate without a robust public option is a gift to the private health insurance industry.
Addendum (9/13/09) David Sirota provides examples of other "triggers" that are legislative bullcrap.
Thursday, August 13, 2009
Big Lies
If different months of the year reflect different personality types, then August must be the month for idiots and liars. All of the reasonable and responsible people are away on vacation so the field of play is left to the nutcases. This is particularly evident this August in the so-called debate (really what has become a shouting match) between the proponents and opponents of health care reform. The pity of it is that with all of the lies and disinformation that are being spread by opponents of health care reform, and the need by the supporters to constantly rebut them, ordinary people are being prevented from learning the facts and hearing about the real issues.
President Obama, who is an admirer of Abraham Lincoln, should recall that he once said that you can "Fool all of the people some of the time, and some of the people all of the time. But you can't fool all of the people all of the time". Lincoln, however, failed to note that in a democratically-governed society all you need to do is to fool most of the people most of the time, and you can get what you want.
That is the strategy that the Republican Party (the GOP -- Guardians of Profit) and their allies in the health insurance industry seem to be counting on to derail Obama's health financing reform agenda. Their preferred tactic is known in the public opinion and propaganda industry as the "Big Lie". It is really very simple to use and usually works quite well.
All one needs to do is to invent a lie so preposterous that most people will think that no one would ever say such a thing if it wasn't true. It is important that the lie be something that induces fear in people and that it be made to seem that the supposed fearful thing is being kept secret. Then one gets a lot of important people to repeat the lie over and over again at every opportunity.
This is why one is hearing about "death panels" and FEMA concentration camps as elements of Obama's health care proposal, and why loyal Republican operatives can be relied upon to repeat these canards on every cable channel new show that will give them a pulpit from which to broadcast their propaganda talking points. When one "big lie" gets debunked they just invent another one and the beat goes on. But all the while the real issues are never discussed as the electorate is being whip-sawed between the conflicting emotions of fear and hope.
The biggest lie the opponents of reform are using these days is the claim that America has "the best health care system in the world." If this is true, then of course there is no reason to reform it and doing so is only likely to make it worse. But this is a outright lie as any objective assessment of the facts would reveal. The three basic criteria for judging national health care delivery systems are access, quality, and cost.
The U.S. health care system does not provide universal access, as for instance, does France or Britain; the health outcomes for the American people are worse that those of many countries, for instance, Canada or Denmark, and the cost per patient to deliver poor care to only a portion of the population is the highest in the developed world. By any objective assessment the U.S. health care system is one of the worst systems found in any rich country, but many people continue to solemnly repeat the claim that it is the best. They do so because the statement has a positive emotional valence to patriotic people, because believing it undermines the argument for reform, and because they know that if it they repeat it often enough with enough sincere feeling, a lot of people will believe it is true.
The political game this month is to see which side can nudge the poll numbers a few percentage points in one direction or another. Recent polls have shown opponents of reform slightly ahead. After the Congress returns from its August recess, there will be a final "scrum" in which compromises will be accepted and deals will be made, and some kind of health care bill will be cobbled together. For members of Congress who are on the fence, or just being cagey, a shift in public opinion about health care reform could sway their votes and mean the difference between legislative victory or defeat for Obama's initiative.
Some commentators have compared the angry demonstrations and shouting at recent town hall meetings to the tactics used by fascist brown shirts in the 1930s. At the same time, Republican propagandists have suggested that Obama and the Democrats are Nazis; Rush Limbaugh has described Obama's healthcare logo as "right out of Adolf Hitler's playbook". Last week someone painted a swastika on the door of democratic congressman David Scott, and a woman at a town brawl demonstration held up a sign with a picture of Obama's face superimposed on a picture of a Nazi stormtrooper.
The opponents of health care reform, having unleashed the dogs "Fear" and "Anger" in order to prevent proponents of reform from actually answering questions from their constituents, are innoculating themselves against the charge that they are behaving like fascists by leveling this same accusation preemptively at their targets. Also, of course, everyone hates Hitler and the Nazis so getting that label to stick to Obama will carry a lot of emotional weight.
All of these tactics and techniques are well known. An earlier politician wrote the following about the use of big lies:
All this was inspired by the principle--which is quite true in itself--that in the big lie there is always a certain force of credibility; because the broad masses of a nation are always more easily corrupted in the deeper strata of their emotional nature than consciously or voluntarily; and thus in the primitive simplicity of their minds they more readily fall victims to the big lie than the small lie, since they themselves often tell small lies in little matters but would be ashamed to resort to large-scale falsehoods. It would never come into their heads to fabricate colossal untruths, and they would not believe that others could have the impudence to distort the truth so infamously. Even though the facts which prove this to be so may be brought clearly to their minds, they will still doubt and waver and will continue to think that there may be some other explanation. For the grossly impudent lie always leaves traces behind it, even after it has been nailed down, a fact which is known to all expert liars in this world and to all who conspire together in the art of lying.
The author of his quote is Adolf Hitler (Mein Kampf, vol. I, ch. X).
Addendum: For the story about who exactly were the expert liars who conspired together to create the myth of death panels see this story in the New York Times.
Wednesday, June 10, 2009
Obama's Strategy for Health Care Reform
Thus far the Obama administration has been letting Congress take the lead in framing legislation to bring about fundamental change in the way Americans get their health care paid for. The bills being developed in Congress currently feature a "public option" that would create a government run and financed health insurance fund that would compete with the big private health insurers, like Blue Cross/Blue Shield, Aetna, Kaiser Permanente, and the other for profit health insurance companies. These companies, as well as the for profit hospitals, the manufacturers of medical equipment and supplies, the big pharmaceutical companies are now launching a massively funded public relations campaign designed to get rid of the public option idea and go on with "business as usual" for another few decades.
At the same time, the Obama plan has ticked off progressives because he and his democratic allies in Congress have decided at the outset to take a "single-payer" option off the table. There was a good discussion of this on Amy Goodman's Democracy Now show the other day with Bernie Sanders and the President of the California Nurses Union, Rose Ann DeMoro in which they both expressed frustration and anger about Congress not taking the single-payer option seriously. The single-payer option is the only possible plan that offers significant cost savings while also ensuring universal coverage. It has been empirically tested and refined in Canada and other countries that have long ago accepted the proposition that health care is a human right, to another opportunity to make a killing in the market. There is a well-developed proposal for a system of national health insurance (see PNHP)
There is no good reason for Congress not to even consider a single-payer option. But perhaps this is a calculated political strategy. The insurance industry and their Republican allies in the Congress are already lining up to oppose the "public option" that they claim will eventually threaten the private insurance business. The public option plan does not have the advantages of the single-payer system in terms of cost saving and administratiive simplicity nor in terms of universality. But it does allow the private health insurance business to stay in existence to compete with a government financed insurance program. But the private insurers and their allies are already whining that by offerring the public a lower cost option for health insurance, the public option will eventually take over the market and price private companies out of the competition.
I believe that this argument is total bullshit -- did all private schools and colleges go out of business when state governments started funding schools? But in any case, what Obama ought to say to this argument is: "OK, if you guys won't let us have the public option which may eventually drive some of your insurance companies out of business, then we are putting the single-payer option back on the table and that is what we will be pushing through Congress this year." Your choice is between accepting a proposal that may put some of insurance companies out of business eventually, or one in which they will all be put out of business immediately. Your choice."
It is likely that if the Democrats in Congress and the President play this particular brand of political hard ball the Republicans will walk and refuse to vote for any plan. But once Al Franken gets seated, the Democrats have enough votes to pass it anyway, without any Republican support. If they avoid the 60 vote threshold by means of reconciliation they will need only 50 votes to pass it in the Senate, and they should be able to do that even if convervative Democrats such as Arlen Spector and Ben Nelson vote with the Republicans.
If the Republicans start screaming bloody murder about employing this tactic to get a long overdue national health insurance bill passed, I suggest that President Obama dispatch Rahm Emanuel to Capitol Hill to convey to them the immortal words that Vice President Dick Cheney said to Senator Patrick Leahy --- "You can go fuck yourselves".